Child Protection System in Scotland
The Scottish Government is responsible for child protection in Scotland. It sets out policy, legislation and statutory guidance on how the child protection system should work.
Child Protection Committees (CPCs) are responsible for multi-agency child protection policy, procedure, guidance and practice.
Within each local authority, CPCs work with local agencies, such as children's social work, health services and the police, to protect children.
The national approach to improving outcomes for children and young people in Scotland is Getting it right for every child (GIRFEC) (Scottish Government, 2015). This provides a framework for those working with children and their families to provide the right support at the right time.
The key guidance for anyone working with children in Scotland is the National guidance for child protection in Scotland (Scottish Government, 2014).
In Scotland, a child legally becomes an adult when they turn 16, but statutory guidance which supports the Children and Young People (Scotland) Act 2014 includes all children and young people up to the age of 18. Where concerns are raised about a 16 or 17 year old, agencies may need to refer to the Adult Support and Protection (Scotland) Act 2007, depending on the situation of the young person at risk. Section 21 of the National guidance for child protection in Scotland explains how professionals should act to protect young people from harm in different circumstances (Scottish Government, 2014).
In Scotland, there is no legal requirement to report concerns about a child's welfare. However, the National guidance for child protection (Scottish Government, 2014a) refers to "collective responsibilities" to protect children.
How to report a concern
If you think a child is in immediate danger, contact the police on 999. If you're worried about a child but they are not in immediate danger, you should share your concerns.
Services will risk assess the situation and take action to protect the child as appropriate either through statutory involvement or other support. This may include making a referral to the local authority.
Getting it Right for Every Child (GIRFEC)
GIRFEC notes that it's everyone's responsibility to ask five key questions when they have concerns about a child.
GIRFEC incorporates the SHANARRI indicators which recognise that every child and young person should be:
The five key questions include identifying barriers to ensuring the wellbeing of the child and asking what professionals or their agencies can do to help the child.
GIRFEC also sets out the role of Named Person for every child in Scotland. When this comes into force, this role will act as the point of contact for children/young people and families, and all others who have a concern about the wellbeing of a child.
Referrals and investigations
Assessing the risk of harm
Local authorities have a legal duty to investigate concerns about a child and assess the risk of harm.
As new information comes to light, the risks to the child must be re-assessed.
If a child's in immediate danger an order can be made through Scotland's sheriff courts (local courts which deal with the majority of civil and criminal cases in Scotland).
Depending on the situation, one of the following actions may be taken:
All of these emergency measures allow time to decide the best way to protect a child. This may involve a case conference and possibly care proceedings.
If a child isn't considered to be in immediate danger then more information will be gathered. This will allow an assessment of whether they are at risk of suffering significant harm.
After this assessment, the professionals involved will decide how to act. They may:
A child protection case conference (CPCC) is held if the child is assessed as being at risk of significant harm. This enables all of the relevant professionals to share information, identify risks and outline what needs to be done to protect the child.
The initial CPCC must take place within 21 days of the original referral to the police or children's social work.
If professionals at the initial case conference decide a child is at risk of significant harm they will add them to the child protection register, and draw up a child protection plan.
CPCCs will continue at regular intervals until the child is no longer considered at risk of significant harm or until they are taken into care.
The CPCC may decide that the best way to protect the child is through legal interventions - either to make sure they get the help they need or to take the child into care.
When that happens, the case is referred to the Children's Reporter who will decide if there needs to be a children's hearing for compulsory child protection measures.
Child protection measures
Child protection register
In Scotland the child protection register (CPR) is a confidential list of all children in the local area who have been identified as being at risk of significant harm. It allows authorised individuals to check if a child they are working with is known to be at risk.
If a child is added to the CPR they must also have a child protection plan, which sets out what action needs to be taken by whom and when, in order to safeguard the child and promote their welfare.
Unless the level of risk requires the courts to get involved immediately, care proceedings will only start after extensive efforts to keep the child with their family.
If the child is still at risk following these efforts then the parents will be invited to a pre-proceedings meeting as a final attempt to avoid going to court.
A child may be taken into care voluntarily through Section 25 of the Children (Scotland) Act 1995.
A local authority must provide accommodation for children who do not have anywhere suitable to live. This includes children who have nobody to look after them or whose parents are unable to look after them for a period of time, due to illness or other problems.
Going to court
In Scotland, there are two different ways a local authority can ask to take a child into care:
A child can be subject to an order from the children's hearing and an order from the sheriff court at the same time.
In all cases, a child should be given the opportunity to give their views if they have capacity. The Children's advocacy guidance (Scottish Government, 2014b) gives information about children's capacity to make decisions.
A child's social worker will make a plan, sometimes referred to as a care plan, setting out how they think the child should be cared for.
The children's hearing will make a decision about the care of the child based on the child's protection, guidance, treatment or control needs. They may make a child protection order.
Under a supervision order a child can either live away from home (in foster or residential care) or continue living at home under the supervision of the local authority.
Once a supervision order has been made the child protection plan will be carried out, regardless of where the child is living.
A compulsory supervision order has no set limit, but should only last as long as is necessary. It must be reviewed by a children's hearing at least once a year when it can be continued, changed or stopped.
After three months a parent of a child can ask for the children's hearing to review the supervision order. A social worker can ask for a review at any time.
A parent, child or social worker can also appeal the decision made at the hearing but this must be done in writing and within strict time limits.
In Getting it right for looked after children and young people (Scottish Government, 2015), the Scottish Government makes it clear that a child's views should be taken into account when deciding where they should live, and that remaining at or returning to their home with the necessary support should be considered as the first option.
If the local authority believes it would not be safe to return a child home, the court can make a permanence order. These orders remove parental responsibility and give it to the local authority.
If adoption is not seen as the way forward the local authority can delegate parental responsibility to the child's foster carers while it remains the legal parent of the child.
If adoption is seen as the best option, the local authority can apply for a permanence order with authority to adopt. This means the local authority can place a child with prospective adoptive parents without the birth parent's consent.
Once a permanence order has been made, prospective adopters can apply to the court for an adoption order. Once an adoption order is granted parental responsibility is transferred to the adoptive parents.
Under Section 29 of the Children (Scotland) Act 1995 (Part II Chapter I Section 29) and Regulation of Care (Scotland) Act 2001 local authorities have a duty to assess the needs of care-leavers in order to provide advice, guidance or assistance to them until the age of 26.
Legislation and guidance
The Children (Scotland) Act 1995 outlines the legislative framework for Scotland's child protection system covering parental responsibilities and rights and the duties and powers local public authorities have for supporting and promoting the safety and welfare of children.
Under Section 29, local authorities have a duty to assess the needs of care leavers up to the age of 26.
This is amended by the Children and Young People (Scotland) Act 2014, which focuses on children and young people in planning services to make sure their rights are respected across the public sector.
In particular, Section 19 describes the role of a Named Person who should advise and support the child or young person in accessing a service or support. This formalises processes already outlined in Getting it right for every child (GIRFEC) (Scottish Government, 2018).
Policy and guidance
Getting it right for every child (GIRFEC) (Scottish Government, 2018)
This is the Scottish Government's approach to making a positive difference for all children and young people in Scotland.
National guidance for child protection in Scotland (Scottish Government, 2014a)
Updated in May 2014, this provides the current guidance and a national framework for anyone who could face child protection issues at work.
This non-statutory guidance is for frontline practitioners, managers and strategic leaders who work with children and families facing adversities.
It gives an overview of the legal framework for providing support services where there is a risk a child may become looked after, and describes who relevant services must be provided for.
National action plan to prevent and tackle child sexual exploitation (Scottish Government, 2016b)
This action plan was updated in March 2016. It explains: